Discussion:
[whispersystems] Add "help-wanted" label
art1fa
2016-04-04 20:30:33 UTC
Permalink
Hey!

What do you think of adding a "help-wanted" label for smaller and
"easy-to-fix" issues for which the core developers currently do not have
the time to look into?
I am speaking of for example the scroll-to-bottom issue (#2856), the iOS
9.1 emoji (#4279) etc.

This might be an additional incentive for non-OWS devs to contribute and
submit PRs that have a good chance to be merged if the contributing
conventions are met.

art1fa
(@agrajaghh @2-4601)
Shankar Kulumani
2016-04-04 20:38:38 UTC
Permalink
I thought there was an "easy" label for this?
Post by art1fa
Hey!
What do you think of adding a "help-wanted" label for smaller and
"easy-to-fix" issues for which the core developers currently do not have
the time to look into?
I am speaking of for example the scroll-to-bottom issue (#2856), the iOS
9.1 emoji (#4279) etc.
This might be an additional incentive for non-OWS devs to contribute and
submit PRs that have a good chance to be merged if the contributing
conventions are met.
art1fa
orta therox
2016-04-05 05:49:35 UTC
Permalink
There’s an Easy Contribution <https://github.com/WhisperSystems/Signal-iOS/issues?q=is:open+is:issue+label:%22Easy+Contribution%22> label, but as an iOS developer who could spend their OSS time on Signal, I see 25 un-merged PRs, and the majority for this year with no comments. This says to me any time I put into Signal is effectively wasted.
--
[A.] Orta Therox
w/ Artsy <http://artsy.net/>CocoaPods <http://cocoapods.org/> / CocoaDocs <http://cocoadocs.org/> / GIFs.app <https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/gifs/id961850017?l=en&mt=12>
@orta <http://twitter.com/orta> / orta.github.com <http://orta.github.com/>
I thought there was an "easy" label for this?
Hey!
What do you think of adding a "help-wanted" label for smaller and
"easy-to-fix" issues for which the core developers currently do not have
the time to look into?
I am speaking of for example the scroll-to-bottom issue (#2856), the iOS
9.1 emoji (#4279) etc.
This might be an additional incentive for non-OWS devs to contribute and
submit PRs that have a good chance to be merged if the contributing
conventions are met.
art1fa
art1fa
2016-04-05 10:20:53 UTC
Permalink
I know there is an "easy" label, but I think it was not meant to
actually ask for contributions.


art1fa
There’s an Easy Contribution
<https://github.com/WhisperSystems/Signal-iOS/issues?q=is:open+is:issue+label:%22Easy+Contribution%22> label,
but as an iOS developer who could spend their OSS time on Signal, I see
25 un-merged PRs, and the majority for this year with no comments. This
says to me any time I put into Signal is effectively wasted.
--
[A.] Orta Therox
w/ Artsy <http://artsy.net/>
CocoaPods <http://cocoapods.org> / CocoaDocs
<http://cocoadocs.org> / GIFs.app
<https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/gifs/id961850017?l=en&mt=12>
@orta <http://twitter.com/orta> / orta.github.com
<http://orta.github.com>
I thought there was an "easy" label for this?
Hey!
What do you think of adding a "help-wanted" label for smaller and
"easy-to-fix" issues for which the core developers currently do not have
the time to look into?
I am speaking of for example the scroll-to-bottom issue (#2856), the iOS
9.1 emoji (#4279) etc.
This might be an additional incentive for non-OWS devs to
contribute and
submit PRs that have a good chance to be merged if the contributing
conventions are met.
art1fa
Mark Somerville
2016-04-05 12:02:04 UTC
Permalink
There’s an [1]Easy Contribution label, but as an iOS developer who
could spend their OSS time on Signal, I see 25 un-merged PRs, and the
majority for this year with no comments. This says to me any time I put
into Signal is effectively wasted.
Yes, although I'm not an iOS developer, this is concerning news to me.

What process (or anything other) changes can contributors make to ensure
this sort of backlog doesn't happen so easily?
blake
2016-04-05 14:36:36 UTC
Permalink
I think the problem is there is no current lead dev for signal on iOS. They've been trying to hire one for a while.
Post by Mark Somerville
There’s an [1]Easy Contribution label, but as an iOS developer who
could spend their OSS time on Signal, I see 25 un-merged PRs, and the
majority for this year with no comments. This says to me any time I
put
into Signal is effectively wasted.
Yes, although I'm not an iOS developer, this is concerning news to me.
What process (or anything other) changes can contributors make to ensure
this sort of backlog doesn't happen so easily?
--
Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
Loading...